Prev

Next

Neshama Interfaith Center Marian Monahan, a founder of the Neshama Interfaith Center, speaks in the voice of a prophet. She preached these words on Mother's Day at the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in Atlanta, and has graciously allowed me to share them here: Those of you who know me are aware that I'm quite involved in the interfaith...

Read more

American Guild of Judaic Art The American Guild of Judaic Art is a not-for-profit membership organization for those with interests in the Judaic arts. Guild Members include artists, galleries, collectors & retailers of Judaica, writers, educators, appraisers, museum curators, conservators, lecturers, and others personally or professionally involved...

Read more

Tiferet: Literature, Art & the Creative Spirit Thanks to the encouragement of Tiferet's editors and community of writers, I've taken risks with my writing—submitting poetry to their site and entering their annual writing contest. Tiferet Talk, featuring interviews with authors, has also been a wellspring of inspiration. Here are links to my most recent posts at Tiferet: Gratitude...

Read more

Encountering Angels: Reading Genesis with my Children In this book, my children and I blend traditional Jewish learning and personal experience in our commentary on Genesis, making it unlike any other book written about the biblical text and rabbinic literature related to Genesis.  Like most books of biblical commentary written by rabbis, it examines the text through the...

Read more

Pamela Jay Gottfried is an ordained rabbi, teacher, mother, and self-described wordie. An inveterate Scrabble player and New York Times Crossword Puzzle fanatic, she credits her love of words to her third grade teacher and her parents, who encouraged her to develop her vocabulary through reading and using the dictionary...

Read more

twitter

Control

10

Watching my 12 year old son set up Google Drive for my friend, listening to him patiently explain the various functions and options, I glimpse a memory of him as a toddler, chatting amiably with a Research Assistant at Emory University.

I no longer recall the details of how we were enrolled in this long-term study of autism, or the particulars of how they knew to call us. Did I sign something in the hospital? I don’t even remember which department was conducting the study. I remember only that, when they called, I readily agreed.

Because of my “advanced maternal age” during pregnancy—I was 35 when he was born—my spouse and I were required to attend a genetic counseling session before declining amniocentesis. That hour of my life gave me plenty of new things to worry about for the following six months. Of course, already a mother of two, I understood that to be a parent is to worry about your children forever.

Like his older sisters, my son reached developmental milestones at appropriate times. Like his older sisters, he was highly verbal, with an estimated vocabulary of more than 50 words in two languages by his first birthday. Around that time, we visited Emory to participate in Part One of the study. The initial test involved his voluntary separation from me, as one Research Assistant led him to the opposite side of the room and conducted a brief interview with him. Then he performed several problem-solving tasks for other researchers, identifying colors on a chart and imitating the language of animals after correctly reciting their names. My confident, self-possessed toddler charmed all of the adults in the room.

emory autism center

Emory Autism Center

About a year later, we were invited for a follow-up session, which consisted of similar but more age-appropriate tasks involving numbers and letters. This time the interview with the Research Assistant was extensive—I was in a separate room watching from behind a glass wall—as he evaluated how well my son read social cues. Did he make eye contact? Speak with a varied vocabulary? Would he shake hands to say goodbye?

As we prepared to leave the building, the Research Assistant thanked me for bringing him for the second visit and reassured me: “Obviously, your son is in the control group.”

Fast forward a decade. My son, whose voice has already dropped an octave, sits with my friend in front of the computer and demonstrates the functions of Google Drive. I glimpse a possible future for him; he could be a computer scientist, an engineer, a graduate student conducting research in neuropsychology. My friend has given me this gift, this hopeful moment as I imagine him as a successful adult.

There is an inspirational story about how he came to be my friend’s I.T. guy, but it’s too long to share all the details now. The abbreviated version is this: last month, he and I attended—at her invitation—a community meeting to discuss a positive and possible future for her daughter, who has autism. The meeting was facilitated by two researchers at Georgia State University, who elicited ideas from her family and friends to help this 12 year old girl connect with the wider community. The facilitator invited neurotypical peers to suggest ways they could relate to her daughter. When the conversation turned to the topic of social media, my son realized that he could help her set up Google Drive to keep a digital scrapbook and journal of their progress. My friend often posts about her family on Facebook, but wants to create a more involved circle of friends, who are willing to go beyond simply liking or commenting on her status.

All the time he is working with my friend, her daughter is also communicating with her, using signs and vocalizations to ask for a snack, to ask if it’s her turn to watch a music video on the computer, to indicate that she’s ready to go home. At times she is occupied with a puzzle in the next room, but she returns often to the table, asking for music. Like my son, she loves music.

I wonder about teenagers and their love of music. I wonder if we all turn into our mothers, shouting at our teenagers to turn down their music.

I wonder if my friend participated with her daughter in the Emory study. I wonder if my son’s participation, in the control group, helped the researchers discover anything worthwhile that might assist those navigating parenthood of a child with autism.

I return to reconsider the researcher’s assurance to me. He certainly understood and recognized the symptoms of autism as they emerge in toddlers, as well as the scientific method that requires a control group. But I understood the practicalities of parenthood; I recognized that there is no control, only the letting go of control.

We parents—whether our children are on the autism spectrum or are neurotypical—have little control over who our children will become as adults. We give the best of ourselves to them when they are toddlers, children and teens. Then we wait. And we worry. We watch with wonder as they grow and change, as they defy our expectations.

Getting to know my son and my friend’s daughter—this visit was only the third time we met and the longest in duration—I glimpsed a positive and possible future for both of our children. I am not yet able to understand her signs or interpret her vocalizations, but I was able to interact with her using a communication device. Rather than feeling helpless about what we cannot control, I feel hopeful. If my friend can learn to use Google Drive, I can learn sign language. Even at an “advanced maternal age,” we can learn new things from our children, in order to give them the best of ourselves and guide them toward adulthood.

Here’s a sample of music that we enjoy together!

Share
10

 

Neshama Interfaith Center

1

mmonahan200Marian Monahan, a founder of the Neshama Interfaith Center, speaks in the voice of a prophet. She preached these words on Mother’s Day at the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in Atlanta, and has graciously allowed me to share them here:

Those of you who know me are aware that I’m quite involved in the interfaith community in Atlanta. I am one of the founders of the Neshama Interfaith Center: no brick and mortar yet. We’re essentially nomads. One of my co-founders—an esteemed colleague and very dear friend—Rabbi Mitch Cohen and I have had many interesting and provocative conversations about who Jesus was and what his mission was. I love to engage my Jewish friends with questions about how they understand who this 1st century itinerant healer and teacher from Palestine was. In one of our recent animated talks, Mitch said that he thought Jesus was a reformer. Agreed. Christians would add to that description: son of God, savior, messiah, prophet.

Yes, prophet. After all, what was the role of the Jewish prophets but to speak into the lives of their contemporaries a message of reform and hope, and to call them back when they had veered off the path of justice, especially when the needs of the widow and the orphan, the foreigner and the poor were not being met? And isn’t that what we see Jesus doing over and over again in the scriptures?

We clearly know from the gospels that Jesus remained in his tradition, faithful to the Hebrew Scriptures and to the rituals and feasts of his Jewish faith, including fellowship meals and Passover. Yet he added new and more expansive interpretations to ancient texts and nuances to some of the rituals. The religious authorities of the day didn’t appreciate the man or the message. And let’s face it, that’s what got him into trouble; he pushed the boundaries of religion and social/cultural mores. And he pushed them because he knew that the God they worshiped was too small, and he knew that the hand of God reached all the way to the fringes of their community, the outcasts. Jesus was subversive and the God of his understanding was dangerous.

We humans sometimes have difficulty reinterpreting or entertaining new ways of thinking. Not everybody thought that Martin Luther King was a hero. Some people refuse to see immigrants as people worthy of the same respect that everyone else deserves. The last hundred years have been full of new discoveries about what it means to be fully human and about the inherent dignity of all people regardless of gender, race, religion, ethnicity or orientation. But growth and change can go hand in hand with pain and resistance, and it’s not always easy to open ourselves fully to what is new and/or different. A closed stance can mean shutting the door to new ways of perceiving or learning and ultimately closing the door to fullness of life.

What a problem this can be when life’s experiences, or those we love, ask us to embrace change! More importantly, we can impede our own spiritual growth by closing and shuttering the windows to our deepest self. God is always calling us beyond the horizon of what we thought was possible.  The Spirit is in the business of more: more compassion, more unity, more diversity, more unconditional non-judgment. We see this especially in the life of Jesus, our safe gate, the door opener, to God.

What Jesus offers in today’s Gospel reading from John is “abundant life” as the “gate for the sheep” and also as our “good shepherd.” Now who could object to such an offer? Yet we know not everyone who heard him or met him got on the Jesus train. His use of shepherd imagery not only recalls Psalm 23 but also must have reminded his hearers of a profoundly powerful text from the prophet Ezekiel:

For the Lord Yahweh says this: Look, I myself shall take care of my flock and look after it. I shall rescue them and shall gather them back from the countries and bring them back to their own land. There they will browse in rich pastures on the mountains of Israel. I myself shall pasture my sheep; I myself shall give them rest. I shall look for the lost one, bring back the stray, bandage the injured and make the sick strong. I shall be a true shepherd to them, declares the Lord Yahweh.

Through Jesus, the compassionate shepherd, we are invited into the rich pastures of our own hearts and the loving heart of God; he promises safe passage and life in abundance. But a gate can keep people out or swing open wide. So how might we interpret this sheep gate?

Scholars of scripture tell us that chapter 10 of John is a further response to the amazing story of Chapter 9: the man born blind. Jesus, once again, pushes the envelope and heals on the Sabbath. The Pharisees, who represent for John the religious establishment, are outraged. The upshot of course is that the blind man is the one who ultimately sees or perceives, and the religious folk, who should see, are blind to the great new work that God is doing in Jesus. This Jesus, reformer, prophet, shepherd, beloved of God, is living and teaching a message of radical inclusion and unconditional love for ALL: lepers, women, the sick and the poor, blind beggars, the imprisoned, the immigrant, the widow, tax collectors and even Samaritans! Jesus stands with—even identifies with—the suffering masses.

So what are the implications for us? I’d like to suggest two things:

First of all, can we dare to believe that the totality of who we are, and nothing less, is loved and loveable; that the desire of God’s heart is that we might have compassion on ourselves? After all, transformation and growth take time. Can we trust in our inherent goodness and believe that we carry within us the divine spark, divine DNA?  Jim Finley says in his book, Christian Meditation: Experiencing the Presence of God: “The beloved says from the other side of the door: ‘open the door and come in, so we can experience just how one we might become.’ God has left the door unlocked and even slightly ajar. God is waiting for you to open it and come walking through to experience that oneness with God that is the fullness of life itself.”

I’m aware from personal experience and from my ministry of Spiritual Direction that this is work, and the work of a lifetime. So let today be the day you open your heart a little bit more. Joyce Rupp says that while Jesus miraculously opened eyes and ears, his deeper message centered on an interior releasing that led people to the freedom of becoming their truest selves. Your authentic self is beautiful and infinitely loved. This is safe passage through the gate.

Secondly, we must now be the shepherds who lead. We must point the way; we must be the reformers and prophets! We must now open our hearts more fully to “the other” and stand with those who suffer. Awareness is key: we must awaken to the societal and cultural injustices that keep people from the fullness of life. Then, once awakened, we must roll up our sleeves; in a city like Atlanta there’s plenty of work to go around. How? Emails and calls to our representatives in government; lives of engagement and nonviolent resistance to classism, racism, sexism, trafficking of our young people; and volunteer work in ministries that alleviate the suffering of the homeless, the poor, the hungry and the undocumented (which the Shrine does so well). To insure safe passage for those who don’t believe or who believe differently, coupled with dialogue across traditions and with those who claim no tradition, to build bridges, not walls. How about an invitation to the “unaffiliated,” who might be seeking ways to be involved yet don’t find their place inside a church, a synagogue or a mosque: “come, let’s work together so that our community, city, neighborhood, and world is a little more compassionate.”  Regardless of a person’s spiritual path, the life of Jesus can provide a template for a joyful, meaningful life, and life in abundance; we find our truest selves when we lose ourselves in loving service.

Richard Rohr says that “that there is an unexplainable goodness at work in the universe” which some of us call God. I see and know this “unexplainable goodness” in my husband, my children, their spouses, my friends, in you. Resurrection means that the Christ works in us, through us and as us, and this is available to all of humanity. We are the human face of Jesus now. Let’s swing the gate wide open.

neshama profile picMarian Monahan is a Spiritual Director, retreat leader and religious educator, who is also trained as a Life Coach through Coaches Training Institute (CTI).  The Neshama Interfaith Center is a community for exploration, spiritual growth and healing; offering diverse classes and services designed to nurture the whole person in a setting where all faith expressions are valued.

Share
1

 

These are the Names

3

These are the names of the Nigerian girls that I included in my morning prayers today:

listofgirlsnames2

There is a blessing in the daily Amidah–the central prayer of Jewish liturgy–that asks God to bring healing of body and spirit to all those who are sick. It is a generic petition, but when we pray on behalf of people it is customary to add their names. This morning, I printed this list of the names of the 177 girls confirmed to be still missing since April 15th and I read them aloud, stumbling over unfamiliar combinations of consonants yet determined to give voice to each individual.  As I read the names, I noticed that many girls share the same surname; I presume that they are sisters taken from the same family.

I think about the hashtag “BringBackOurGirls,” now trending on Twitter, and remember that Nigerian women introduced this phrase to social media while they demanded that their government take action, while they protested and raised their voices, at no small risk to their own safety.

My own girls are at school this morning–one roams freely across a college campus in the city and the other walks confidently through the halls of a suburban high school. They are relatively safe at school. Still, as I recite the names of the missing Nigerian girls, I want to race to my girls’ schools and hold them close to my heart.

I silently acknowledge that we mothers are powerless to prevent violence against our daughters. I wish someone would print a list of the names of the mothers whose daughters are missing–the mothers who are suffering just as surely as their daughters are. I would pray for every mother by name.

Shemot 1 web

The biblical book of Exodus begins by listing the names of Jacob’s sons who went down to Egypt, names that are familiar to us from the book of Genesis. Why list their names again?  Obadiah Sforno, a commentator who lived in 16th century Italy, explains: “They are mentioned here, as it is suitable that their names be known, that every one of them be considered as a person, by the name that is the expression of their individuality.”

These are the names of the Nigerian girls. Let every one of them be considered as a person. Let each one of them be mentioned by name in our prayers until all return safely to their mothers.

Share
3